New research reveals that plant-based meat alternatives often lack nutritional value

concept of nutritional value

The examine reveals that the dietary worth of meat options presently in the marketplace is usually insufficient, primarily based on elements equivalent to uncooked materials choice (typically imported soybeans), processing strategies (antinutrient content material), and added components (fats high quality, salt).

The emergence of plant-based protein choices as options to meat has grown considerably as extra people undertake a plant-based weight loss plan. Nonetheless, the dietary worth of those merchandise remains to be a priority. Examine from Chalmers College of Know-how It was present in Sweden that most of the meat substitutes bought in Sweden include a excessive proportion of iron, however it’s in a kind that the physique can’t take in.

Anne Sophie Sandburg

Professor Anne-Sophie Sandberg, Division of Biology and Organic Engineering, Chalmers College of Know-how. Credit score: Chalmers

A weight loss plan consisting largely of plant meals equivalent to root greens, pulses, fruits, and greens has an total low local weather affect and can be related to well being advantages equivalent to lowered danger of age-related diabetes and heart problems, as has been proven in a number of massive research. . However there have been far fewer research on how individuals’s well being is affected by consuming merchandise primarily based on what are generally known as plant proteins.

Within the new examine by Chalmers, a analysis staff on the Division of Meals Science and Vitamin analyzed 44 totally different meat substitutes bought in Sweden. The merchandise are made primarily from soy and pea protein, but in addition embrace fermented soybean product and mycoproteins, that’s, proteins from fungi.

“Amongst these merchandise, we noticed nice variance in dietary content material and the way sustainable they had been from a well being perspective. Typically, the estimated absorption of iron and zinc from the merchandise was very low. It’s because these meat options include excessive ranges of phytates, antinutrients that inhibit the absorption of minerals in physique, says Cecilia Meyer-Lappa, lead writer of the examine, who lately defended her thesis on dietary restrictions for switching from animal protein to plant-based protein.

The physique loses important minerals

Phytates are discovered naturally in beans and grains – they accumulate when proteins are extracted to be used in meat substitutes. Within the digestive tract, the place minerals are absorbed, phytates kind insoluble compounds containing important dietary minerals, notably non-heme iron (Iron present in plant meals) and zinc, which implies they can’t be absorbed within the gut.

Iron and zinc additionally accumulate in protein extraction. For this reason excessive ranges are listed among the many components of the product, however the minerals are sure to the phytates and can’t be absorbed and utilized by the physique,” says Cecilia Meyer-Laba.

Cecilia Mayer LBA

Dr. Cecilia Meyer-Labba, Division of Biology and Organic Engineering, Chalmers College of Know-how. Credit score: Martina Butorac/Chalmers

Iron deficiency amongst girls is a widespread world downside. In Europe, 10 to 32 % of ladies of childbearing age and about one in three adolescent ladies in secondary faculty in Sweden are affected. Girls are additionally the group probably in society to modify to a vegetarian weight loss plan and eat the least quantity of crimson meat, which is the principle supply of iron that’s simply absorbed within the digestive tract.

Clearly, in terms of minerals in meat options, the quantity obtainable for absorption by the physique is an important consideration. You possibly can’t simply have a look at the components listing. A few of the merchandise we studied are fortified with iron however nonetheless inhibited by phytates. We imagine that making dietary claims about these vitamins that may solely be absorbed by the physique can create incentives for business to enhance these merchandise, says Ann-Sophie Sandberg, professor of meals science and vitamin at Chalmers and co-author of the examine.

The meals business wants new methods

Tempeh, which is made out of fermented soybeans, differed from different meat options within the quantity of iron obtainable for the physique to soak up. This was anticipated, for the reason that fermentation of tempeh makes use of microorganisms that break down phytate. Fungal proteins had been characterised by their excessive zinc content material, with out containing any recognized absorption inhibitors. Nonetheless, in accordance with the researchers, it’s nonetheless not clear how our intestine can break down the cell partitions of the fungal protein and the way this, in flip, impacts the absorption of vitamins.

Plant-based meals are vital for the transition to sustainable meals manufacturing, and there’s large improvement potential for plant-based meat options. The business wants to contemplate the dietary worth of those merchandise and benefit from and enhance recognized course of methods equivalent to fermentation, but in addition develop new methods to extend the absorption of assorted vital vitamins,” says Cecilia Meyer-Laba.

Manufacturing of plant proteins

  • Most plant protein merchandise in the marketplace are primarily based on protein extracted from a cultivated plant, equivalent to a soybean, and separated from different plant components.
  • The protein is then subjected to excessive stress and temperature, which restructures the proteins, generally known as construction so {that a} extra meaty and chewy product may be obtained together with the opposite components.
  • Chalmers’ examine reveals that the dietary worth of meat options obtainable immediately is usually poor relying on the selection of uncooked supplies (typically imported soybeans) and processing situations (antinutrient content material), and on components (fats and salt high quality).
  • A 150-gram serving of meat various contributes as much as 60 % of the utmost really helpful each day quantity of salt, which is 6 grams in accordance with Northern Vitamin suggestions.

Reference: “Dietary composition and estimated bioavailability of iron and zinc for meat substitutes obtainable on the Swedish market” By Inger Cecilia Meyer-Lappa, Hannah Steinhausen, Linnea Almius, Knud-Erik Bach-Knudsen, and Anne-Sofi Sandberg, Sept. 21, 2022, Out there Right here. Vitamins.
DOI: 10.3390/nu14193903

The examine was funded by the Birtibus Basis, the Swedish Analysis Council, and Västra Götaland Area.

Leave a Comment